Riddles and food have coexisted for centuries. Our exhibition focuses on culinary riddles from the 18th-20th centuries. Culinary riddles were dinnertime games to be discussed, debated, and solved by guests around the table.

Scroll down to begin

Enigmatic Bills of Fare (1)

Many of the riddles in this exhibition originated in 18th-19th century Britain. These were known as Enigmatic Bills of Fare (EBoFs).

Enigmatic Bills of Fare (2)

Enigmatic Bills of Fare were riddling menus guests would be expected to solve before ordering their meals. Many EBoFs were copied and circulated extensively among upper class circles.

Enigmatic Bills of Fare (3)

Most of the EBoFs we found originated in the United Kingdom. However, by the 19th century, we also found them in the United States.

Enigmatic Bills of Fare (4)

This suggests that during the 19th century, EBoFs were taken across the Atlantic. You can read more about EBoFs here.

Conundrum Suppers (1)

Starting from the 19th century, we discovered hundreds of culinary riddles and riddling events from across the United States.

Conundrum Suppers (2)

Most of them were known as Conundrum Suppers. These were events from the 19th and 20th centuries, where guests would gather for riddling menus, games, and other conundrum-themed forms of entertainment.

Conundrum Suppers (3)

Conundrum Suppers were hosted primarily by Protestant Church communities across the United States. They often doubled as fundraising events during which guests would order à la carte from enigmatic menus.

Conundrum Suppers (4)

Funds would often go toward Church renovations or communities in need. We found many menus from this period; click on the dots to see the riddles. You can read more about Conundrum Suppers here.

NYS Conundrum Suppers (1)

These events were especially popular in New York State state and were often publicised by local newspapers. Two newspaper archives are represented here: New York State Historical Newspapers and Fulton History.

NYS Conundrum Suppers (2)

These two archives alone contain evidence for 500 riddling dinners. While there are clusters in urban areas, most of the events we discovered took place in rural areas.

US Riddling Dinners

Events from these archives were not unique to NY. While Conundrum Suppers seem to be more popular in the North-East, we found events from many different states across the country.

Canadian Riddles (1)

We have even found riddling events in Canada. We have found a few events in British Columbia, as seen on the map...

Canadian Riddles (2)

...and there are several scattered throughout Alberta and Saskatchewan as well.

Canadian Riddles (3)

These riddling practices were even found in Quebec, some of which were published by Montreal newspapers. Events shown on the map are from the Bibliothèque et Archives nationales du Québec.